Print Page | Close Window

Does all horror need a content warning?

Printed From: NYC Midnight : Creative Writing & Screenwriting
Category: GENERAL DISCUSSION
Forum Name: Creative Writing Corner
Forum Description: Discuss NYC Midnight Creative Writing Competitions or Creative Writing in general.
URL: https://forums.nycmidnight.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=51677
Printed Date: 28 Mar 2024 at 11:29am
Software Version: Web Wiz Forums 12.05 - http://www.webwizforums.com


Topic: Does all horror need a content warning?
Posted By: CoachLisaB
Subject: Does all horror need a content warning?
Date Posted: 21 Jan 2023 at 4:12pm
I'm wondering this because I read one today that included something that is listed in the NYCM content warning list and would rather not have read it - but there wasn't a CW/TW. Then it occurred to me that maybe most of what we write about in horror could disturb someone. I've written horror twice and didn't include a content warning because I didn't consider the violence to be particularly graphic, but maybe I should have.

FYI, here's the link to the post about content warnings:
https://forums.nycmidnight.com/tips-for-using-the-review-forum-content-warnings_topic50445.html" rel="nofollow - https://forums.nycmidnight.com/tips-for-using-the-review-forum-content-warnings_topic50445.html


-------------
Will do my best to return reads!
https://forums.nycmidnight.com/topic56786_post611140.html#611140" rel="nofollow - R1-250
https://coachlisab.com/archive" rel="nofollow - Archive



Replies:
Posted By: SDWatts
Date Posted: 21 Jan 2023 at 4:23pm
I think the all horror is probably triggering to someone, so reading horror is agreeing to a certain kind of risk regarding disturbing content, but including a cw/tw lets the reader decide what specific kinds of  triggers they're agreeing to expose themselves to. 


Posted By: taaaylor
Date Posted: 21 Jan 2023 at 4:23pm
As a general rule, I don't include content warnings to judges. I assume that 1) the judges are warned about what type of content is allowed to be submitted and 2) it's not worth risking losing points by including something that isn't technically the synopsis, title, or story itself. If NYCM added an optional line on the submittable form for content warnings, that would be great -- assuming that no one is penalized for not being aware a CW should be listed, as it's a somewhat new concept and people without trauma may have no awareness of what should or shouldn't be warned about.

I generally give TWs on posts for real-world trauma or phobias people can really experience. But for example, I wrote horror in round 1 of the rhyming contest, and the "horror" of my story was someone getting trapped in a haunted crossword chatroom. That isn't a real world trauma, so it didn't need a TW :)

I do think it's okay to request people to add trigger warnings. I've done it myself. If you want someone to ask for you, feel free to PM me a link

ETA: Here's another example of a classic horror story with no need for a TW:  https://www.americanfolklore.net/hairy-toe/" rel="nofollow - https://www.americanfolklore.net/hairy-toe/


-------------
https://t.ly/JlEAs" rel="nofollow - SSC R1
https://t.ly/XFj6f" rel="nofollow - 250 Micro R2

SSC 2021 winner


Posted By: nod1v1ng
Date Posted: 21 Jan 2023 at 4:56pm


All horror does not need a CW. Something to think about when writing horror is there is a difference between phobias and trauma. I wouldn't put a CW on a horror story about spiders, even though some readers might be arachnophobic. Horror historically leans on phobias to amp up fear. 

Same thing for paranormal horror. I wouldn't put a CW on a story about monster or ghosts, even though they can be scary. Horror is supposed to be scary. 

However, if your story, horror or otherwise, could potentially make a reader relive their own trauma, then a CW is worthwhile. If you feel like it might spoil the story, use the "spoiler" function (or put it in white text that a reader can highlight to reveal.) This way the reader can decide if they want to read the spoiler or not.

I feel like NYCm's guidance is reasonable for what subjects require a CW. But I agree with taaaylor that you can suggest someone adds one. If a reader makes the suggestion that you add one, then add it. It hurts no one, and might make a difference to someone's mental health.


 


-------------
https://shorturl.at/pOW45" rel="nofollow - SSR1
https://rb.gy/i8cxfo" rel="nofollow - 250R2


Posted By: Draiglas
Date Posted: 22 Jan 2023 at 9:32am
Originally posted by taaaylor taaaylor wrote:

 If NYCM added an optional line on the submittable form for content warnings, that would be great -- assuming that no one is penalized for not being aware a CW should be listed, as it's a somewhat new concept and people without trauma may have no awareness of what should or shouldn't be warned about.

There actually is! It's not on Submittable but when you go to the backup screen on the NYCM midnight page after submitting, they now say in the box for notes something like "Optionally, you may wish to include content warnings for the judges here". I have included content warnings when I don't think it's a massive spoiler in that box (e.g. for FF R4 I didn't since the twist was what caused the trigger warning, but for MF250, I did).

(For the forums, I always include content warnings regardless of twist on the basis that forum readers haven't signed up to read potentially traumatic stuff. I sometimes add non-required ones if I think it's necessary or polite).


-------------
http://tinyurl.com/yc58xfbf" rel="nofollow - MF250 R2
http://tinyurl.com/exfj9cz6" rel="nofollow - MF250 R1
Others


Posted By: CoachLisaB
Date Posted: 23 Jan 2023 at 8:27pm
Originally posted by taaaylor taaaylor wrote:

As a general rule, I don't include content warnings to judges. 


I generally give TWs on posts for real-world trauma or phobias people can really experience. 


I do think it's okay to request people to add trigger warnings. I've done it myself. If you want someone to ask for you, feel free to PM me a link

ETA: Here's another example of a classic horror story with no need for a TW:  https://www.americanfolklore.net/hairy-toe/" rel="nofollow - https://www.americanfolklore.net/hairy-toe/

Thank you! I wouldn't consider a CW for the judges; definitely just wondering for the forums. I did suggest to the person that they might want to add a warning; thank you for offering, though! Now off to read the story you linked!


-------------
Will do my best to return reads!
https://forums.nycmidnight.com/topic56786_post611140.html#611140" rel="nofollow - R1-250
https://coachlisab.com/archive" rel="nofollow - Archive


Posted By: CoachLisaB
Date Posted: 23 Jan 2023 at 8:28pm
Originally posted by Draiglas Draiglas wrote:

There actually is! It's not on Submittable but when you go to the backup screen on the NYCM midnight page after submitting, they now say in the box for notes something like "Optionally, you may wish to include content warnings for the judges here". I have included content warnings when I don't think it's a massive spoiler in that box (e.g. for FF R4 I didn't since the twist was what caused the trigger warning, but for MF250, I did).

Cool! I never noticed it there.


-------------
Will do my best to return reads!
https://forums.nycmidnight.com/topic56786_post611140.html#611140" rel="nofollow - R1-250
https://coachlisab.com/archive" rel="nofollow - Archive


Posted By: CoachLisaB
Date Posted: 23 Jan 2023 at 8:33pm
Originally posted by nod1v1ng nod1v1ng wrote:

All horror does not need a CW. Something to think about when writing horror is there is a difference between phobias and trauma. I wouldn't put a CW on a horror story about spiders, even though some readers might be arachnophobic. Horror historically leans on phobias to amp up fear. 

Same thing for paranormal horror. I wouldn't put a CW on a story about monster or ghosts, even though they can be scary. Horror is supposed to be scary. 

However, if your story, horror or otherwise, could potentially make a reader relive their own trauma, then a CW is worthwhile. If you feel like it might spoil the story, use the "spoiler" function (or put it in white text that a reader can highlight to reveal.) This way the reader can decide if they want to read the spoiler or not.

I feel like NYCm's guidance is reasonable for what subjects require a CW. But I agree with taaaylor that you can suggest someone adds one. If a reader makes the suggestion that you add one, then add it. It hurts no one, and might make a difference to someone's mental health.

Great points regarding the distinction between phobia and trauma - thank you! I did suggest a CW would be helpful on this particular story, and I later discovered that NYCM suggests a CW for this topic, so I don't think I was out of line.


-------------
Will do my best to return reads!
https://forums.nycmidnight.com/topic56786_post611140.html#611140" rel="nofollow - R1-250
https://coachlisab.com/archive" rel="nofollow - Archive


Posted By: slinkylink
Date Posted: 28 Jan 2023 at 11:34am
Originally posted by Draiglas Draiglas wrote:

It's not on Submittable but when you go to the backup screen on the NYCM midnight page after submitting, 

I just submitted my short story and see that the content warning option is now on both the main page and backup page. I'm 99% sure it wasn't on the main page for 250 because I would have included it for mine. I'm glad that the CW aren't visible to the judges! That will definitely encourage me to include them next time. 

"While not mandatory, please consider adding content warnings if your story includes graphic sexual content, graphic violence, or anything else you feel would need a warning for the reader. This will not be visible to the judges. But, if any judges would like to opt-out from receiving groups containing certain material, it will help us assign them to different groups. Thank you very much!"


-------------
http://tinyurl.com/4rhmkn5n" rel="nofollow - 250 R2
https://tinyurl.com/56jhx7f8" rel="nofollow - SW R1
https://tinyurl.com/knd8sme9" rel="nofollow - Archive


Posted By: Draiglas
Date Posted: 28 Jan 2023 at 12:21pm
Originally posted by slinkylink slinkylink wrote:

Originally posted by Draiglas Draiglas wrote:

It's not on Submittable but when you go to the backup screen on the NYCM midnight page after submitting, 

I just submitted my short story and see that the content warning option is now on both the main page and backup page. I'm 99% sure it wasn't on the main page for 250 because I would have included it for mine. I'm glad that the CW aren't visible to the judges! That will definitely encourage me to include them next time. 

"While not mandatory, please consider adding content warnings if your story includes graphic sexual content, graphic violence, or anything else you feel would need a warning for the reader. This will not be visible to the judges. But, if any judges would like to opt-out from receiving groups containing certain material, it will help us assign them to different groups. Thank you very much!"

Yeah, I saw that when I did a safety submission earlier. Maybe I was the only person who noticed the CW thing on the backup page so they just decided to make it more obvious now LOL


-------------
http://tinyurl.com/yc58xfbf" rel="nofollow - MF250 R2
http://tinyurl.com/exfj9cz6" rel="nofollow - MF250 R1
Others


Posted By: LilyCat
Date Posted: 28 Jan 2023 at 3:46pm
I typically say "no horror" when I put my name on the beta list, but this time I had to write horror, so... I wrote something that wasn't overtly violent and focused instead on psychological horror, not graphic.

I did decline to beta a story that triggered some of my PTSD, but there's no way the writer would have known about it as it was personal to me, not a common trigger. And that author wasn't writing horror, so it wasn't on them to post any warnings, IMO. It was on me to back away and let it go.



-------------
https://forums.nycmidnight.com/r3-g4-drama-mouse-trouble_topic53801.html" rel="nofollow - R3 G4 Mouse Trouble


Posted By: annemarie
Date Posted: 28 Jan 2023 at 4:01pm
In my opinion, anyone who reads a horror story should expect some level of violence and gore.  Unless your story deals with some really specific scenes (child abuse, animal torture or the like), I'd say no.

-------------
SS R1 https://rb.gy/ml87fi" rel="nofollow - Mystery
Rhyming R2 https://shorturl.at/diGQW" rel="nofollow - Romance


Posted By: mistressposte
Date Posted: 28 Jan 2023 at 7:25pm
This is a great question. When I entered the FF (1000 words, I think) I assumed that horror didn't need a CW. But some of the negative feedback was about the violence - it never occurred to me that that could be an issue. However, a CW means that your story will only be shared with judges who are happy to read that kind of content so I will definitely include one moving forward. 

-------------
http://bit.ly/42ohqcP" rel="nofollow - SCR2 Gr2
http://bit.ly/3o8E0Yt" rel="nofollow - SCR1 Gr60
http://bit.ly/3Du0urO" rel="nofollow - SS R1 GR159


Posted By: taaaylor
Date Posted: 28 Jan 2023 at 11:52pm
NYCM organizers, if you read this: THANK YOU for adding a space for content warnings on the main submission page! It's a sincere relief to be able to write about difficult topics while giving the courtesy of a warning to judges. I am diagnosed with PTSD, and content warnings truly matter for people who are in different stages of healing from trauma. I'm honestly really heartened to see NYCM display such respect and regard for their readers.

I'm just so relieved and so happy. What a great addition Embarrassed Clap Thank you Charlie and co.! 


-------------
https://t.ly/JlEAs" rel="nofollow - SSC R1
https://t.ly/XFj6f" rel="nofollow - 250 Micro R2

SSC 2021 winner



Print Page | Close Window

Forum Software by Web Wiz Forums® version 12.05 - http://www.webwizforums.com
Copyright ©2001-2022 Web Wiz Ltd. - https://www.webwiz.net